It’s almost a rite of passage: grabbing a t-shirt from one of Key West’s legendary watering holes. Think Sloppy Joe’s, Captain Tony’s, or Hog’s Breath Saloon. These shirts aren’t just souvenirs—they’re badges of honor for surviving Fantasy Fest!
Just remember, some quotes that feel hilarious after a rum punch or two (we’re looking at you, Captain Tony) might raise eyebrows back home—especially at PTA meetings or kid-friendly outings. Choose wisely, and maybe skip the ones with questionable quotes if you plan to wear it beyond your laundry room.
Key West and Key Lime go together like flip-flops and sunshine. Even though Key limes aren’t grown commercially on the island anymore, you’ll find their tart-sweet flavor in everything from cookies to sauces to lip balm.
Be sure to stop by Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe for some free samples and maybe stock up on a pie or two (they ship!). These goodies make great gifts…if you don’t eat them all before you get home.
Simple, stylish, and surprisingly affordable, Kino Sandalss are a true Key West tradition. Handmade since 1966 using natural leather and time-honored techniques, these sandals are as comfortable as they are classic.
Swing by their shop at 107 Fitzpatrick Street to see the artisans at work—even if you’re not shoe shopping, it’s a neat experience. And hey, your feet probably deserve a reward after all that dancing during Fantasy Fest.
Thanks to Key West’s Cuban heritage, the island has a rich history of cigar making. While Cuban cigars are still off-limits, you’ll find plenty of shops selling high-quality hand-rolled options, crafted using old-school methods passed down by Cuban immigrants.
Whether you’re a cigar aficionado or just want a cool gift for someone who is, a hand-rolled cigar from Key West is both traditional and distinctive.
If you’re feeling a bit more treasure hunter than tourist, consider jewelry inspired by the famous Spanish galleon, the Nuestra Señora de Atocha, which sank near the Keys in 1622.
While original Atocha coins cost a pretty penny, many shops sell beautiful replicas—some even made from silver recovered from the wreck. You’ll also find ocean-themed charms, sea turtles, and nautical designs that make beautiful souvenirs (and are way easier to carry home than a shipwrecked treasure chest).
